The Toronto Maple Leafs’ goaltending situation has been a persistent cause for concern, and the opinions are as divided as ever. Some see the potential for a breakout season, while others are already bracing for disaster.
First, let’s talk numbers. Joe Woll led the NHL in playoff GAA and Sv% last season, even if it was just three games. Anthony Stolarz? He led the regular season in those same stats and was a solid backup. And then there’s Matt Murray, a two-time Stanley Cup winner. All three goalies come in at a combined $4.1 million—a bargain for goaltending talent, right?
Well, not everyone is convinced. While some are hyped about this trio, others think it’s a risky gamble. The concerns are real: Woll has played fewer than 40 regular-season games in his career and has struggled with injuries.
Stolarz, despite his solid numbers last season, has never played more than 28 games in a single NHL season. As for Murray, let’s be honest—his Cups were won seven years ago, and since then, injuries have plagued his career.
Some fans are feeling the burn, claiming, “This feels like a ticking time bomb.” The potential is there, sure, but it’s a thin line between success and a full-on goalie meltdown. Stolarz has shown flashes of brilliance, and Woll’s talent is undeniable—when he’s healthy.
Also Read: Leafs betting Big on Oliver Ekman-Larsson over Tyson Barrie might come back to bite – Leafs Herald
But with both goaltenders’ limited experience and Murray’s injury history, the cracks in this plan are hard to ignore. It’s like betting on a race car that’s super fast but prone to breaking down.
Still, there’s hope among the more optimistic for the next season. If coach Berube manages to rotate the goalies smartly—maybe a 30-30-20 split between Woll, Stolarz, and Murray—there’s a chance this could work. The key is keeping them fresh and healthy, and if all three stay in top form, it might just be the best goaltending Toronto has seen in a long time.
But others are quick to point out, “You all said the same thing last year, and the year before, and the year before…. it’s just a sad sad song at this point.” The Leafs have a history of goaltending issues, and while this trio has the potential to change that narrative, it could just as easily fall apart. Whether it’s Woll’s injuries, Stolarz’s limited workload, or Murray’s shaky past, there are more question marks than exclamation points.
So, is this the best goaltending the Leafs have had in years? Or is it another chapter in their never-ending goalie drama? The truth is, nobody knows for sure, but the upside is there. If Woll stays healthy, Stolarz holds steady, and Murray finds his form, this could be a sleeper success. But if not, well…Yikes.